A U.S. federal judge has dismissed part of music publisher Wixen’s copyright lawsuit against Meta while allowing its remaining infringement, trade libel and defamation claims to proceed, according to Digital Music News. The ruling narrows the dispute over music used on Meta’s platforms but leaves its central allegations unresolved.

Judge John Walter’s order followed Meta’s October motion to dismiss Wixen’s second amended complaint, Digital Music News reporter Dylan Smith reported. The judge found that Wixen could not pursue infringement claims involving the pre-1978 works at issue without the copyright owners joining the lawsuit.

“Under the 1909 [Copyright] Act, copyright interests were traditionally treated as indivisible, such that an exclusive licensee ‘may not alone maintain an infringement action’ without joining the ‘copyright owner,’” Walter wrote, as quoted by Digital Music News.

Because those owners were not plaintiffs, the judge found that Wixen lacked standing to bring those claims. Meta’s other dismissal arguments, Walter wrote, “are more appropriately resolved on a motion for summary judgment.”

The case began earlier in 2026 after a music-licensing relationship broke down. Wixen alleged that Meta, Instagram’s owner, offered renewal terms that would have “drastically” reduced songwriter royalties. The publisher claimed the proposal aimed to replace royalty-bearing, human-created music with royalty-free AI-generated music.

Wixen also alleged that Meta allowed music covered by the expired agreement to remain available for incorporation into “thousands” of users’ Reels, infringing the works involved.

A separate strand of the complaint concerns Meta’s alleged explanations for music takedowns. According to Wixen’s allegations, Meta blamed the publisher when affected music professionals asked why their material had been removed. Wixen claimed those statements cost it clients.

The lawsuit was dismissed without prejudice in September. Wixen then filed a revised complaint alleging infringement of 569 works, down from 681 previously. The latest order allows the remaining claims to advance without deciding whether Meta committed the alleged infringement or defamation.

Sources