Alice Merton’s copyright infringement lawsuit against Kanye West has been dismissed, apparently after the parties reached a settlement, Digital Music News reported Nov. 13. The dismissal follows a judge’s refusal last month to remove references to antisemitism from the case.

The German musician sued West, who now goes by Ye, in March 2025, alleging that his track “Gun to My Head” used an uncleared sample of her song “Blindside.” Merton, a descendant of Holocaust survivors, said she had specifically refused permission because of West’s history of antisemitic statements and behaviour.

West’s legal team sought to strike references both to his antisemitism and to Merton’s family connections to the Holocaust. His lawyers argued that those details had no bearing on whether copyright infringement had occurred.

Federal Judge Fernando L. Aenlle-Rocha rejected that request, finding that the material could help explain Merton’s decision not to authorize the sample.

“The court finds that the allegations concerning Merton’s background or Ye’s alleged remarks are not unduly prejudicial and may have some bearing on the litigation, including potentially at trial to explain Plaintiffs’ rationale for denying Defendants’ use of Plaintiffs’ song,” the judge wrote, according to Digital Music News.

That ruling concerned which allegations could remain in the lawsuit, rather than a determination that West had infringed copyright. The reported dismissal now brings the dispute to a close without a trial ruling on Merton’s allegation.

Digital Music News described a settlement as the apparent reason for the dismissal but did not report financial terms or other conditions of an agreement.

The dispute connected Merton’s refusal to license her work with West’s public conduct. The outlet reported that West had praised Hitler, sold swastika merchandise on his website and proclaimed himself a Nazi, a declaration he later attempted to walk back.

Sources