Universal Music and Sony Music are opposing a full halt to their second copyright case against AI music platform Suno, proposing instead to pause some evidence-gathering while allowing scrutiny of newer models and business activity to continue.
According to Digital Music News, the labels outlined their position in a response spanning nearly 20 pages. Suno asked in late October for the newer case, UMG v. Suno II, to be put on hold while the first lawsuit proceeds.
The dispute centres on how much litigation should continue before the court resolves the fair-use question in UMG v. Suno I. Suno argues that findings in the first case could undermine the labels’ theories of liability in the second, making parallel proceedings burdensome and potentially unnecessary.
In its motion, Suno said a ruling that its conduct was fair use, or that YouTube’s technological measures do not support a claim under Section 1201(a), could foreclose the plaintiffs’ arguments in the newer lawsuit.
Universal and Sony accept that some work can wait. They support temporarily suspending discovery into ownership of the more than 60,000 sound recordings asserted in the second case. But they oppose freezing the entire action, warning that a full pause could realistically extend into 2028 while Suno continues developing and commercializing its models.
Their alternative would permit what they describe as tailored discovery into Suno’s v6 products and ongoing model-training practices. It would also cover the company’s finances and commercial footprint, including new features, fundraising and presentations to investors.
The labels also propose making evidence gathered in the first lawsuit usable in the second, arguing that this would address Suno’s concerns about duplication.
The second action followed an unsuccessful attempt to add roughly 60,000 allegedly infringed works to the original case. The judge rejected that expansion because it would delay resolution indefinitely, but left open a separate complaint, Digital Music News reported.
Discovery disputes in the first case remain active, alongside third-party subpoena clashes involving companies and organizations including Nvidia, Apple, DistroKid and the Mechanical Licensing Collective.



Leave a comment
Join the discussion. Please follow our Community Standards.
Sign in or create an account to leave a comment.
Choose your public display name before submitting. Your email address stays private.
No published comments yet.