A Chicago HIV researcher has dropped cash payments from a federally funded study after U.S. National Institutes of Health officials required changes to the project, according to reporting by The Guardian’s Jessica Glenza.
Dr. Jade Pagkas-Bather had planned a randomized controlled trial testing whether monthly payments of $500 would help young people living in poverty who are HIV-positive stay on treatment. Her premise was that hunger and unstable housing could make managing HIV less of a priority.
Before receiving funding in June 2025, she said, NIH program officers asked her to remove references to gender identities and a statement about higher poverty rates among Black and Latinx people. She made those changes and enrolled dozens of participants.
In 2026, officials asked for a more fundamental revision: eliminating unconditional cash transfers. Pagkas-Bather told The Guardian she was ultimately informed that keeping the payments would mean finding $1 million elsewhere for her $1.3-million project.
She instead plans to offer food and transportation vouchers. Participants will need to consent again because the revised study differs substantially from the one they joined.
Her experience comes amid a broader NIH grant-renegotiation process that the agency says has affected more than 5,000 new and continuing grants. The Guardian reported that the process uses a text-analysis tool to flag projects considered out of alignment with Trump administration priorities.
An analysis by Grant Witness, an independent group tracking cancelled government grants, found changes to titles, abstracts or public-health statements in 8.6 per cent of continuing grants in 2025 and 8.5 per cent in 2026, compared with 0.4 per cent in 2023. Those figures document textual changes, not the precise number of scientists subjected to renegotiation, which remains unknown.
The NIH defended the process, telling The Guardian that renegotiation has long been used for various reasons and that human experts assess every renegotiated grant. A spokesperson said changes replaced poorly defined or subjective concepts with objective, measurable variables.
Pagkas-Bather is among 14 named plaintiffs in a lawsuit alleging that grant renegotiations and cancellations violate the First Amendment through viewpoint-based discrimination. A federal court hearing in November is to consider whether the case can proceed as a class action, The Guardian reported.



Leave a comment
Join the discussion. Please follow our Community Standards.
Sign in or create an account to leave a comment.
Choose your public display name before submitting. Your email address stays private.
No published comments yet.