The UK government is considering changes to legal-cost protections that environmental lawyers warn could prevent community groups from challenging planning decisions affecting nature, The Guardian reports.
According to the newspaper’s reporting by Matthew Pearce and Pippa Neill, environmental lawyers say the Ministry of Justice has held private meetings with selected stakeholders about reducing protections associated with the Aarhus convention. The government says it remains committed to the treaty and has no plans to remove protection for well-founded claims.
The convention, which became UK law in 2005, guarantees participation in environmental decision-making. Its cost protections are intended to keep environmental legal challenges from becoming prohibitively expensive for individuals and public-interest groups.
Under the existing arrangements described by The Guardian, an individual who loses an environmental claim pays no more than £5,000 toward the opposing side’s costs. The cap for organisations is £10,000.
Possible changes include removing those protections, doubling cost caps at each stage of a challenge, or withdrawing protection when a court finds a “misuse of judicial review.” Another option would expose groups that crowdfund unsuccessful challenges to costs of up to 70% of the money raised. These are reported proposals, not announced changes to the rules.
Carol Day, a senior environmental solicitor at Leigh Day, told The Guardian the changes would “bring environmental litigation almost to a halt.” She said the government had not supplied hard evidence demonstrating that such cases were holding up development.
Sarah Finch, whose grassroots judicial review concerning an oil well in Surrey changed UK climate law, said her group would never have brought its case if it had risked paying the other side’s legal fees.
Lawyers also expressed concern that the discussions could move the UK toward leaving the convention, something the government denies. Day argued that the potential changes could leave the country significantly out of compliance with its obligations.
A government spokesperson told The Guardian: “The government is committed to upholding its obligations under the Aarhus convention, including maintaining access to environmental justice that is not prohibitively expensive. There are no plans to remove costs protections for well-founded claims.”



Leave a comment
Join the discussion. Please follow our Community Standards.
Sign in or create an account to leave a comment.
Choose your public display name before submitting. Your email address stays private.
No published comments yet.