Meta would have to consider withdrawing encrypted services from Canada if Parliament passes the government’s lawful access legislation without further changes, company representatives told a Senate committee Monday evening, CBC News reports.
The warning concerns Bill C-22, which would require technology companies to adapt their systems so they can provide information to investigators with a warrant. Meta’s services include Facebook, Instagram and the encrypted messaging app WhatsApp.
Robyn Greene, Meta’s director of privacy and public policy, told the national security committee that complying with the proposed law would be incompatible with maintaining secure, end-to-end encrypted services for Canadians. The company argues the requirements would leave information intended only for the users exchanging it vulnerable to malicious actors.
Asked whether Meta would pull services from Canada, Rachel Curran, its head of public policy for Canada, said the company would “review all of our options” and would have to “consider” withdrawal. Her comments did not amount to a decision to leave.
The bill would also allow the minister to issue confidential orders requiring electronic service providers operating in Canada to build surveillance and monitoring capabilities into their systems. Those orders would first undergo review by the intelligence commissioner, an independent quasi-judicial official.
Before the legislation went to the Senate in June, Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree introduced amendments limiting when companies would have to decrypt information. Another change shortened the proposed metadata retention period to six months from up to a year, following cybersecurity experts’ warnings that retained data could attract hackers.
Curran said those changes protect encryption’s core but not surrounding layers integral to the process.
Other technology companies have raised similar objections. Signal vice-president Udbhav Tiwari reiterated that the encrypted messaging service would leave Canada rather than compromise users’ security. Apple said earlier this month that the amended bill could still undermine its privacy and security features.
The government argues the legislation is needed to give law enforcement tools to prevent, investigate and respond to modern crime.
Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne has also sought further amendments. The bill would lower the threshold for accessing basic subscriber information from “reasonable grounds to believe” to “reasonable grounds to suspect” an offence has occurred or will occur. Dufresne said the definition of that information, and who could be required to provide it, remain too broad for the lower threshold.
Source: CBC News reporting by Darren Major, with files from Catharine Tunney and The Canadian Press.




Leave a comment
Join the discussion. Please follow our Community Standards.
Sign in or create an account to leave a comment.
Choose your public display name before submitting. Your email address stays private.
No published comments yet.