Alberta’s proposed removal of diversity, equity and inclusion from public-sector hiring is drawing sharply different assessments of whether it would make recruitment fairer or undermine efforts to address barriers to employment.

According to reporting by Emily Williams for CBC’s West of Centre, Premier Danielle Smith and Justice Minister Mickey Amery say their merit-based hiring bill would ensure the best-qualified candidates are selected. Critics question whether the government has identified a problem that requires legislation.

The changes would affect hiring by provincial public agencies, including Crown corporations, post-secondary institutions, school boards and municipalities, once the bill receives royal assent and comes into force.

Diversity, equity and inclusion, commonly shortened to DEI or EDI, is a framework intended to promote fair treatment and participation for people from different backgrounds. The dispute centres on whether measures designed to address underrepresentation support merit-based hiring or conflict with it.

CBC cited a former University of Alberta policy as an example of the practices the bill would target. When two candidates were equally qualified, hiring panels were instructed to favour someone from a historically underrepresented group. The university changed that policy last spring after a provincial panel recommended greater institutional neutrality.

Calgary-based DEI consultant Hagir Sail rejected the suggestion that such policies necessarily lower hiring standards. She told CBC that bias and systemic barriers can limit people’s opportunities.

The Alberta Union of Provincial Employees has also said DEI hiring practices were not used in ways that would be unfair or encourage bias.

Political assessments are divided, including among former senior figures in the governing United Conservative Party. Former deputy leader and cabinet minister Leela Aheer said DEI helps recruit the best people and argued that the legislation sends a troubling message to vulnerable Albertans.

Erika Barootes, a former principal secretary to Smith, offered the opposite assessment, saying policies introduced with good intentions had gone too far and needed correction. Opposition NDP Leader Naheed Nenshi has characterized the government’s move as a “culture war” rather than a response to voters’ priorities.

The proposal follows another provincial measure, described as the “Peterson law,” which eliminated mandatory DEI training for regulated professions. The hiring bill would extend the government’s policy shift to recruitment across a broad range of public institutions.

Sources