The National Congress of American Indians is urging U.S. President Donald Trump to reverse his order directing federal agencies to call Lake Ontario “Lake America,” warning that replacing Indigenous geographic names risks erasing history.

A resolution adopted at the organization’s October assembly calls on the U.S. federal government to suspend use of the new name, according to reporting by Alessia Passafiume of The Canadian Press, published by Global News. The Seneca Nation of Indians, based in western New York, introduced the resolution.

The congress represents American Indian and Alaska Native tribal governments in the United States. It says the August executive order disrespects Indigenous names and the cultural, spiritual and historical relationships Indigenous peoples have with lands and waters.

Its resolution extends beyond Lake Ontario, urging governments, geographic naming authorities and public and private organizations to preserve Indigenous names in consultation with affected Tribal Nations.

“The National Congress of American Indians opposes the removal, replacement, or erasure of Indigenous names of lakes, rivers, mountains, and other geographic features,” the resolution says.

The name Ontario has roots in Indigenous languages. The lake is known in Seneca as “sga:nyodai:yoh,” meaning “beautiful lake,” and in Wendat as “ontari:io,” meaning “the lake is beautiful, the lake is big.” The name Lake Ontario predates both Canada and the United States.

The resolution describes the lake as a place used by Seneca and other Haudenosaunee peoples since time immemorial for travel, trade, diplomacy, subsistence and cultural practices.

Trump’s directive drew dismay from Haudenosaunee communities on both sides of the border. Wendat Nation Grand Chief Pierre Picard told The Canadian Press his nation was “shocked” by the renaming, which he characterized as an attempt to eradicate its history in the region.

The Wendat historically occupied parts of the St. Lawrence Valley extending to the Great Lakes, an area rich in trade routes before and after European contact.

Prime Minister Mark Carney has rejected the change, saying the body of water remains Lake Ontario “then, now and always.”

Sources