A federal hearing on Powell River Energy Inc.’s application to export all its electricity to the United States for 30 years ended Friday, Nov. 20, with the company and opponents divided over domestic access to power and the future of a former mill site in Powell River, B.C.

The Canada Energy Regulator says it usually decides export-licence applications within 12 weeks of a hearing, CBC News reported. The regulator described this as its first hearing on an electricity export application.

PREI, a subsidiary of Brookfield Renewable Partners, operates two dams that supplied the local mill before it closed in 2021. It has exported its electricity to the United States since the closure, according to CBC’s reporting by Maryse Zeidler.

The company argues that a 30-year contract is necessary to secure financing for facility upgrades. It says its operations generate about $10 million in taxes and other revenue for the region.

PREI lawyer Scott Birse told the hearing that B.C. Hydro was the only interested domestic buyer, but two years of negotiations failed to produce an agreement.

“B.C. Hydro did not offer a price and terms and conditions that were competitive,” Birse said, according to CBC. He argued that the regulator’s rules require good-faith negotiations, not a domestic buyer’s right of first refusal.

B.C. Hydro disputed that account in its final arguments Friday. Lawyer Michelle Casey alleged that PREI had not negotiated in good faith or offered the Crown corporation the same deal. Details of the negotiations and the U.S. agreement remain confidential.

The proposed licence also faces opposition from the Tla’amin Nation and Cranberry Business Group, which have taken over the former mill site and say additional power is needed to attract industrial tenants and restore jobs.

PREI maintained that the export arrangement would not adversely affect the nation and that B.C. Hydro could supply the site. It also said the nation had not confirmed development plans or its electricity requirements.

The nation’s lawyer, Jennifer Griffith, disputed those arguments. She said industrial-level service would require substantial B.C. Hydro system upgrades and argued that the licence would affect Aboriginal title rights and economic interests. She also raised concerns about potential effects on lands and fish habitat.

The City of Powell River, the regional district and Energy Democracy for B.C. also intervened against the proposal. The regulator received more than 2,500 written submissions opposing the application when it was first submitted.

Sources