Victoria’s major parties face warnings that their energy plans will not adequately address the loss of a major coal-fired power station in 2028, putting electricity supply and household bills at risk in the Australian state.

Experts interviewed by The Guardian ahead of this month’s state election say the approaching closure of Yallourn, combined with rising electricity demand, requires faster development of replacement generation and the transmission lines needed to connect it.

The Latrobe Valley plant supplies about a fifth of Victoria’s energy and has operated since the 1970s. All parties accept that it is nearing the end of its functional life and will close, The Guardian reported.

Tim Baxter, of consultancy Naru Research, said declining Bass Strait gas supplies make the transition more pressing. He said gas prices had risen 62% in five years, compared with an 18% increase in electricity bills.

“Every windfarm, solar farm and battery that comes online before 2028 reduces how much expensive gas Victoria has to burn when Yallourn goes,” Baxter told The Guardian.

The Coalition, led by Liberal leader Jess Wilson, proposes scrapping VNI West, a planned electricity connection between Victoria and New South Wales, and pausing the Western Renewables Link between Melbourne and western Victoria. It would commission an independent review of transmission plans, considering alternatives including commercial and industrial rooftop solar.

The Coalition also promises to expand gas exploration, reverse the requirement for new homes to be all-electric and seek new firming capacity through an Energy Security Requirement. It has not proposed changing Victoria’s emissions targets, but The Guardian reported that it had not explained how it would meet them.

Labor says it would expand the grid, continue shifting household heating and cooking from gas to electricity, and support offshore wind development. However, it is also reviewing the Western Renewables Link. Analysts told The Guardian that replacement infrastructure is not being built quickly enough under Labor either.

According to the report, the state’s auditor general says both major transmission projects are behind schedule and unlikely to be completed before Yallourn closes.

The projects also face landholder opposition. Victorian Farmers Federation president Ryan Milgate criticised Labor’s expansion of compulsory acquisition and access powers. The Coalition promises to repeal those powers and restore landholder appeal rights.

Nexa Advisory chief executive Stephanie Bashir said transmission is essential both for renewable generation and for importing electricity during high-demand periods such as heatwaves.

“We do need to back the replacement generation,” she told The Guardian. “We can’t do any more reviews; we’ve just got to get on with it.”

Source: Petra Stock’s reporting for The Guardian.

Sources