The University of Toronto’s response to a report on discrimination against Muslims, Arabs and Palestinians is “wholly insufficient,” the working group’s chair says, while the university’s president maintains the school accepts that discrimination is occurring but cannot endorse the report as written.
Speaking to CBC Radio’s Metro Morning on Monday, law and history professor Anver Emon said the university had rejected the working group’s report and its 57 recommendations. He argued that measures such as improving Muslim prayer spaces, while necessary, do not address the structural problems the group identified.
“The university effectively denies that there are structural considerations that it needs to address,” Emon told CBC.
The nearly 300-page report drew on consultations with 85 people and small groups, along with 525 survey responses from students, staff, faculty and librarians across the university’s three campuses. According to CBC’s reporting, it identified a “general pattern of over-policing and under-protecting” Muslims, Arabs and Palestinians, and described discrimination rooted in stereotypes portraying them as terrorists, misogynists and antisemites.
University president Melanie Woodin disputed Emon’s characterization of the response.
“There’s no rejection. We didn’t accept the report as written,” she told Metro Morning.
Woodin acknowledged a discriminatory environment for Muslim, Arab and Palestinian students, calling it unacceptable. She said aspects of the report conflicted with university commitments involving academic freedom, collective agreements, institutional neutrality and the limits of its jurisdiction.
The recommendations include reviewing safety and risk assessments, ensuring content-neutral policing of protests and postering, and giving administrators stronger guidance on fair complaint handling and decisions to cancel or postpone events.
The report also raises concerns about bias in partnerships with school boards and affiliated hospitals. It recommends considering an investment prohibition involving activities that aid or abet violations of fundamental international legal norms.
Emon contrasted the university’s response with its full acceptance of recommendations from earlier working groups addressing anti-Black racism, antisemitism and anti-Asian racism. He said he had worked with administrators from May through September to check the report’s accuracy and the feasibility of its recommendations.
In its written response, the university committed to further work on appropriate Muslim prayer and multi-faith spaces at all three campuses. Its human rights, equity and inclusion office will also release an educational module on discrimination against Muslims, Arabs and Palestinians and hold an information session for governing council members.
Reporting attributed to CBC, including Metro Morning, with files from Paola Loriggio and Kathryn Mannie of The Canadian Press.



Leave a comment
Join the discussion. Please follow our Community Standards.
Sign in or create an account to leave a comment.
Choose your public display name before submitting. Your email address stays private.
No published comments yet.