The Lancet has retracted a Canadian study that linked an Ontario infant’s death to codeine passed through breast milk, after a Toronto hospital investigation found that omitted toxicological data amounted to falsification. The 2006 paper helped shape international guidance on breastfeeding and pain management for nearly two decades, CBC News reports.

The retraction appears in the journal’s issue set for release Nov. 21. The paper’s authors included Gideon Koren, founder of the former Motherisk laboratory at Toronto’s Hospital for Sick Children, known as SickKids.

The case report concerned an infant who died in Ontario in 2005. It proposed that codeine in the mother’s prescribed Tylenol 3 was converted into morphine in her body and passed to the baby through breast milk in a fatal amount. Tylenol 3 contains acetaminophen and codeine.

According to the retraction notice quoted by CBC, The Lancet referred allegations about the paper to SickKids and subsequently received the findings of a formal research-integrity investigation.

The omitted information included the infant’s blood concentrations of codeine and acetaminophen, as well as the identification of codeine in the infant’s stomach contents.

“The omitted findings left readers without the information necessary to assess the publication’s conclusion,” the journal’s notice said.

SickKids confirmed to CBC that its inquiry determined the omission constituted falsification under the hospital’s Responsible Conduct of Research Policy. It declined to disclose further findings, citing the confidential nature of research-integrity inquiries.

The notice also said authorship issues and ethical concerns could not be fairly investigated because meaningful participation by Koren was unlikely to be possible.

The retraction follows years of scrutiny, including a New Yorker investigation in January and an expression of concern added by The Lancet in February over allegations involving toxicological data, authorship and ethics.

Dr. David Juurlink, a Toronto internist and pharmacologist who has long challenged the study, told CBC its influence extended beyond the explanation of one infant’s death.

“The narrative that babies can die through opioids passed through breast milk has greatly influenced postpartum pain care,” he said. Juurlink argued that the paper had led women taking opioids to forgo breastfeeding, and described the retraction as “a long time coming.”

Source: CBC News — Lauren Pelley’s reporting on The Lancet retraction.

Sources