A developer-commissioned study estimates a proposed data centre in Saint John, N.B., could generate $25 million a year in municipal property taxes, but opponents question whether the projected benefits justify the project’s environmental and health implications.

According to reporting by Global News, the study also forecasts $18 million in annual provincial property taxes from the proposed Spruce Lake development. Beacon Data Centers, which is pursuing the project alongside U.S.-based VoltaGrid, commissioned the report.

Consultant David Campbell, president of Jupia Consultants Inc., estimated a taxable value of $1 billion for the nearly $6 billion project. His calculation included land, buildings and power infrastructure. Campbell said the eventual tax revenue could vary by several million dollars, potentially coming in considerably higher or slightly lower.

Those estimates are not an official assessment. Service New Brunswick, the agency responsible for assessing properties, told Global News it considers factors including land, building size, construction, age, condition, replacement costs and market values. Its approach depends on the property, available evidence and information supplied by the owner.

Mayor Donna Reardon welcomed the projected revenue, saying it could help repair aging pipes and roads, improve transit and parks, and potentially lower residents’ taxes.

“I was shocked to hear the number,” Reardon told Global News.

She noted that machinery and equipment are not currently taxable in New Brunswick. Reardon wants the province to consider taxing equipment at new industrial sites and allowing municipalities to retain all heavy-industry property-tax revenue.

For Save Lorneville, a citizens’ group opposing the project, the financial projections do not resolve its concerns.

“Our community stance is that no dollar value can compensate for what our community is actually losing,” member Chris Watson told Global News.

Watson questioned the results of noise and air-quality testing for the development, which would draw electricity from NB Power and use on-site natural gas generation.

The study also projects 210 permanent jobs and as many as 2,900 construction jobs at peak activity. Beacon told Global News the benefits depend on regulatory approvals and construction, and that authorities will determine the final property assessment and tax bill.

Sources