A CBC Marketplace investigation into six popular mobile apps in Canada found that some appeared to send shopping searches, location details and device information to outside companies, raising concerns among privacy specialists about how much data everyday services collect.

The investigation examined Tim Hortons, PC Optimum, the Weather Network, Facebook, Amazon and YouTube. University of Calgary computer science associate professor Joel Reardon and his team scanned network traffic on Android, while privacy-compliance organization Privo examined the apps on Apple’s iOS.

The apps disclose data collection or sharing in their policies, CBC reported. But Reardon and independent analyst Celeste Rollason questioned whether some collected more than necessary.

The Tim Hortons app appeared to transmit information to third parties upon launch. Reardon said one overseas company appeared to receive enough information to create a digital fingerprint identifying a device over time.

Tim Hortons told Marketplace the service supports fraud prevention, account protection and payment-abuse prevention, not advertising. It said the provider cannot sell the information and that Tim Hortons does not sell users’ personal information to third parties or data brokers.

PC Optimum appeared to send product searches to 10 outside companies, including searches for potentially sensitive items such as prenatal vitamins. One third party appeared to receive a device identifier and latitude and longitude.

Loblaw said it has never sold personal information and that information collected through its apps supports features such as online shopping and finding nearby stores.

When location access was allowed, the Weather Network appeared to send location information to a third party for targeted advertising. Reardon said a persistent device identifier could link those details into a location history.

Parent company Pelmorex said it does not sell user data, uses location only with permission and allows people to check forecasts without sharing their location.

Facebook appeared to collect metadata from photos and videos that users had not uploaded after receiving camera-roll access. It also tracked scrolling and viewing time. Meta declined comment; its policy discloses such collection and says it does not sell information.

The scans did not show Facebook, Amazon or YouTube sending information to third-party companies during testing. Amazon appeared to collect searches alongside an advertising identifier. A separate YouTube test found no targeted ads while a children’s video played. Amazon and Google said they do not sell personal information.

Canada’s federal privacy commissioner’s office told Marketplace the findings raised “a number of concerns.” Former Ontario privacy commissioner Ann Cavoukian urged companies to collect only necessary information and delete it when no longer needed.

Reardon and Rollason recommended deleting unused apps and keeping only those people need, while warning that users have limited ability to stop data transmission.

Sources