A secret recording played at a Toronto kidnapping trial Friday became the focus of a dispute over whether Aiden Pleterski helped stage his own abduction or was trying to escape his captors, CBC News reported. A defence lawyer argued the audio supported a hoax; Pleterski denied that account.

Alfredo Paladino, Akil Heywood and Rakeem Henry are on trial in Ontario Superior Court for allegedly kidnapping and extorting Pleterski in early December 2022. Paladino and Henry also face firearm and assault charges.

According to CBC reporter Nicole Brockbank’s account, the recording captures Pleterski discussing luxury watches, gold bars and cars he said his former landlord, Sandeep Gupta, was hiding for him.

Leora Shemesh, who represents Paladino, suggested the alleged kidnappers recorded the conversation as an “insurance policy” to establish that the kidnapping was staged. She described Pleterski as sounding “cool and collected.”

“This is the plan and a roadmap of how this kidnapping is going to play out,” Shemesh told him during cross-examination.

Pleterski testified that the recording was made after his abduction and an initial beating. He said he lied about Gupta holding assets because he wanted his alleged captors to arrange an in-person meeting with the landlord, creating an opportunity to escape.

Shemesh also challenged his account of his injuries. She suggested they resulted from a fight with another alleged kidnapper, known as “Slime,” who is not among the defendants in this trial. Her contention was that the man became upset when a plan to obtain money from Gupta failed and police became involved.

Pleterski denied that explanation. He has testified that his alleged captors beat and tortured him during a three-day ordeal, leaving cuts, burns and bruises. Under questioning Friday, he confirmed he did not seek hospital treatment.

The Crown alleges Heywood, who lost a significant amount investing with Pleterski, drove the kidnapping while Paladino and Henry carried it out.

Pleterski was convicted of fraud last month over more than $30 million taken from investors and has not yet been sentenced, CBC reported.

Shemesh completed her cross-examination Friday. Pleterski was expected to return Monday for questioning by Henry’s lawyer.

Sources