Australian department store chain Myer has a financial cushion as rival David Jones enters administration and prepares to shut half its stores, but heavy discounting and weaker profitability leave its own turnaround under pressure, The Guardian reports.

David Jones is closing 19 of its 38 locations. Myer, by contrast, finished its last financial year with A$100 million in net cash, giving management room to restructure without the immediate debt pressures that overwhelmed its competitor, according to Jonathan Barrett’s reporting for The Guardian.

Myer’s sales rose at a double-digit rate to A$4.1 billion last financial year. However, that growth reflected the addition of apparel chains Just Jeans, Jay Jays, Portmans, Dotti and Jacqui E, acquired from Solomon Lew’s Premier Investments, rather than a surge in underlying demand.

Its annual report said the company used “higher than planned promotional activity to stimulate demand,” reducing profitability. Myer also cut the value of its brands by more than A$200 million over the year.

The difficulties extend beyond either company. Market researcher IBISWorld described a sustained loss of relevance for department stores over five years, as online platforms attract bargain-hunters and specialist retailers respond to changing tastes. Cost-of-living pressures have also reinforced shoppers’ preference for deals, while long leases leave both chains exposed to underperforming locations.

Myer has reduced its department store network from 60 locations before the pandemic to 56, lowering lease liabilities. It is also pursuing online sales and using promotions to attract customers to its Myer One loyalty program.

David Jones’ retreat could eventually help. Roughly two in five Myer stores share a shopping centre with a David Jones outlet, and Myer shares rose on the day its rival entered administration, The Guardian reported. In the nearer term, however, clearance promotions at closing David Jones stores could draw shoppers away.

Richard Hemming, editor of Under The Radar Report, told The Guardian that maintaining sales volumes could position Myer to benefit if customers later become willing to pay more. Analysts remain divided over whether persistent discounting offers a route to recovery or further financial trouble.

Retail Doctor Group chief executive Brian Walker summed up the distinction: “As we sit here today, Myer is financially stronger, but strategically still pretty vulnerable.”

Sources