A Manitoba judge has awarded damages to both sides of a neighbours’ dispute over loose rescue dogs in the rural municipality of Alexander, granting a couple $10,100 and the dog owner $1,000 after finding that each side had trespassed.

The Nov. 16 Court of King’s Bench decision distinguishes between the dog owner’s ongoing failure to control her animals and the couple’s single act of throwing dock boards into a kennel, according to reporting by CBC’s Ozten Shebahkeget.

Justice Sheldon Lanchbery wrote that the couple bought their Winnipeg River property in 2015. Its forest and walking trails offered privacy, but the woman who purchased the neighbouring property around 2017 began keeping rescue dogs and allowing them to roam.

The judge found that she exceeded the municipality’s limit on dogs. Although evidence about the number was inconsistent, she had at least seven before the COVID-19 pandemic. Lanchbery described the dogs as feral and said their aggressive tendencies continued after rescue.

The couple said they were afraid to walk in their wooded area. The man testified that one dog bit his shin and that he injured a hand when he punched the animal.

Attempts to settle the conflict gave way to security cameras, photographs, competing property surveys and boulders placed near a disputed boundary. The dog owner asked the couple to share the cost of a fence. They refused, partly because they considered controlling the dogs her responsibility.

The dispute later involved a dock the woman placed on the couple’s property. After the man threw broken boards from it into her kennel, she sued. One dog suffered an eye injury, but Lanchbery said the evidence suggested the boards were probably not the cause. There was no evidence the dog was inside the kennel when the boards were thrown.

The judge awarded the couple $10,000 in general and aggravated damages over the dogs, plus $100 for the dock and cars placed on their land.

He nevertheless called the board-throwing an “intentional act of intimidation” and awarded the dog owner $1,000. He rejected an argument that the man’s military training showed he had exercised restraint by not injuring the dogs.

Neither side received legal costs. By the end of testimony, Lanchbery wrote, the neighbours “were painfully aware this was not their finest hour.”

Source: CBC Manitoba reporting by Ozten Shebahkeget.

Sources