A federal judge on Friday, Nov. 20, declined to release Oscar Belgal, a man shot by immigration agents during his October arrest in New York, leaving him in federal custody while deportation proceedings continue. The judge found that a possible procedural error in serving his arrest warrant did not require his release, The Guardian reported with Associated Press reporting.

US district judge Hector Gonzalez wrote that agents may have served Belgal with an arrest warrant before giving him a notice to appear in immigration court. Gonzalez characterized that as a technical error and rejected the argument that the agents lacked a valid warrant.

The ruling follows an Oct. 8 encounter in which immigration officers shot Belgal, a 28-year-old Dominican national, as he drove his five-year-old son home from school. Belgal suffered wounds to his shoulder and neck. His son was not injured.

According to The Guardian’s report, security footage released by New York City police shows a plainclothes officer running toward the car with a gun pointed at Belgal, then using its barrel to break the driver’s window. A second officer draws his weapon as Belgal pulls away. The chase ends moments later with his bullet-riddled car coming to a stop.

Federal officials said officers fired because they believed their lives were in danger. They alleged that Belgal struck two government vehicles and accelerated toward other officers.

Belgal’s lawyers said the agents did not identify themselves before approaching the car, breaking the window and firing. They said he learned the men were immigration officers only after waking in hospital.

The lawyers also argued that excessive force during the arrest violated his due process rights. Gonzalez said the petition seeking release was not the appropriate venue for that argument.

“It is unconscionable that Mr Belgal should have to endure another day in detention, separated from his family, particularly given everything he has already suffered,” the Legal Aid Society, which represents him, said in a written statement.

Belgal entered the United States illegally in 2021, according to the report. He later pleaded guilty to grand larceny and received probation. A separate 2025 case involving allegations that he attempted to sell controlled substances remains pending.

Gonzalez noted that Belgal can still ask the immigration court for release on bond.

Sources