Google has rejected a UK government request to remove Russell Brand’s prison message from YouTube, prompting former safeguarding minister Jess Phillips to say new online safety legislation may be needed to address prisoners communicating through large social media accounts.

According to The Guardian’s reporting by Ben Quinn, the request came through the Prison Service amid warnings that the video was distressing sexual abuse survivors. The dispute has exposed questions about the government’s power to require platforms to remove this type of content.

Brand’s wife, Laura, broadcast the message to his channel’s 6.6 million subscribers days after his conviction for sexual offences. In it, Brand denied guilt despite the jury’s verdict. The video had attracted almost 850,000 views, The Guardian reported.

The Ministry of Justice has opened an investigation into whether Brand breached prison rules. That inquiry is separate from the government’s request for Google to remove the video.

Google said its teams were investigating the content. A spokesperson also said Brand’s channel had been suspended from the YouTube partner programme since September 2023 and could not earn money through YouTube.

Speaking to BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, Phillips, a Labour MP, said the government lacked the power to compel removal of distressing content of this kind. She criticised voluntary online safety measures and suggested regulatory changes, potentially including a second Online Safety Act, were likely to be needed.

The existing act, passed in 2023 and being introduced in phases, addresses illegal content and protections for children. It does not explicitly address prisoners using social platforms to communicate directly with the outside world, according to The Guardian.

Children and families minister Josh MacAlister urged Google to follow Meta, which had disabled Brand’s accounts under its community standards. Housing minister Matthew Pennycook also backed removal, describing the message as harmful to victims.

Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch took a more cautious position. While expressing concern about prisoners sending messages through intermediaries, she said Brand’s wife was a separate person and questioned demanding removal from a private platform before establishing whether a law had been broken.

Sources