A federal appeals court has temporarily stayed a permit allowing the U.S. Army to detonate several tons of unstable bomb-making chemicals near Middletown, Iowa, leaving a planned Monday operation in doubt amid concerns about lead contamination.

The 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals granted the stay late Thursday after environmental groups challenged an emergency permit issued earlier this month by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, The Associated Press reported. As of Friday’s report, the court had not announced a hearing or a timetable for its next ruling.

“The Army can’t detonate under the permit while the permit is stayed,” said Thien Chau, an attorney with Earthjustice, which filed the petition for the Iowa groups.

Federal government attorneys said they would respond by Sunday. In a filing, they argued that the Army can treat hazardous waste without a permit in emergencies involving an immediate threat to health, safety, property or the environment.

The dispute concerns several dozen barrels of degraded lead azide discovered in March at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant. The chemical is used in munitions production. Officials say crystallization has made the material unstable and that falling temperatures could increase the danger of an uncontrolled explosion.

The Army had initially planned the detonation for Friday, then postponed it until Monday following public concern. Acting Army Secretary Adam Telle said the delay would take the operation to the latest possible point before a forecast temperature drop.

According to EPA documents cited by AP, officials considered chemical treatments to neutralize or decompose the contents but concluded that handling the drums would increase the risk of a fatal accidental detonation. The environmental groups argue that alternatives were not fully considered and that officials disclosed too little information.

The Army presented its plans at an October meeting in Middletown, a community of nearly 400 people southeast of Des Moines. But a public advisory issued Sunday was the first notice for other communities, including some about 160 kilometres away.

The advisory warned that a detonation would release a plume containing lead particles that could settle on the ground. Some schools and businesses planned closures. The Army recommended staying indoors, bringing animals inside and closing doors and windows, followed by cleaning outdoor surfaces in the plume’s path.

Lucy Giehl, who lives about 6.4 kilometres north of the plant, told AP she still had questions about cleaning safely and protecting her dogs’ drinking water.

Reporting source: Hannah Fingerhut and Susan Montoya Bryan, The Associated Press, via CityNews.

Sources