Five Cascio siblings have sued attorney Bryan Freedman in California state court, alleging he misled them into signing 2019 agreements that barred them from discussing alleged sexual abuse by Michael Jackson. The lawsuit challenges Freedman’s role in negotiating the deals, claiming he represented the siblings while also working for Jackson’s estate.

According to Digital Music News’ report by Ashley King, Frank, Edward, Dominic, Aldo and Marie-Nicole Cascio filed the case Wednesday, alleging legal malpractice, breach of fiduciary duty and fraud. Those claims, and the underlying abuse allegations, remain allegations rather than court findings.

The siblings allege that documents presented by the estate described the settlement as an “acquisition and consulting agreement” involving the purchase of their life story rights. Under the arrangement, the estate made five annual payments of $690,000 to each sibling in exchange for public silence about Jackson’s alleged sexual abuse. The agreements also included mandatory arbitration provisions, Digital Music News reported.

The family’s connection with Freedman began five years before those agreements. Edward Cascio retained him on the estate’s recommendation after being sued while publicly defending Jackson against sexual abuse allegations and defending the estate in connection with his work on a posthumous release. The estate paid his legal fees, according to the report.

The siblings now allege Freedman also represented the estate when the 2019 agreements were signed, including in litigation against HBO over its broadcast of *Leaving Neverland*.

They claim they discovered the alleged conflict only in 2024, when Freedman allegedly told them the estate had paid too little and described the earlier deal as “toilet paper.”

According to the report, the siblings subsequently retained a separate lawyer, who notified the estate that they would challenge the agreements. The estate then filed an arbitration demand alleging that the siblings had breached the deals’ confidentiality and nondisparagement provisions.

Sources