Prosecutors used a diabetes expert excluded from treating patients to help secure convictions against two Birmingham parents over their son’s death, the Guardian reported on Saturday, raising questions about disclosure of concerns affecting expert evidence.
Prof Peter Hindmarsh produced an August 2023 report used in the prosecution of Damion and Tamara Thomas after their 12-year-old son, Joshua, died. University College London hospitals trust had excluded Hindmarsh from clinical practice that March because of safety concerns, including advice involving insulin, according to David Conn’s reporting for the Guardian.
The newspaper reported that prosecutors learned of the restrictions before the parents’ trial, but jurors were not told about them.
Joshua died at Birmingham children’s hospital on December 10, 2022. Postmortem examinations found severe diabetic ketoacidosis, a critical condition caused by a severe lack of insulin. Doctors identified it as his first episode of diabetes.
The prosecution argued that his parents should have recognised the symptoms and sought medical assistance earlier. Hindmarsh’s report said the symptoms described at 4 a.m. on December 9 should have prompted a medical assessment. Tamara called an ambulance at 12:33 p.m.; Joshua stopped breathing during the call, and she performed CPR under emergency call handlers’ instructions.
In March 2026, Tamara was convicted of gross negligence manslaughter and neglect. Damion was acquitted of manslaughter but convicted of neglect. They received prison sentences in June of three years and nine months, and two years and nine months, respectively.
Both maintain their innocence and have applied for permission to appeal.
According to the Guardian, the Crown Prosecution Service independently discovered restrictions affecting Hindmarsh in November 2025. After further inquiries, it informed defence lawyers on December 9, 2025, before trial, and decided it could continue relying on him.
Expert witnesses must disclose information that could undermine their opinions or credibility. Disclosure specialist Tim Green KC told the newspaper that this must happen “as soon as reasonably practicable”. Hindmarsh declined to answer the Guardian’s questions about the investigation, clinical exclusion or disclosure.
The regulatory position was distinct from the hospital’s restriction. An April 2023 medical tribunal declined to suspend Hindmarsh’s registration and explicitly allowed his non-clinical expert work to continue. The General Medical Council investigation ended without a final adjudication after he voluntarily left the medical register in November 2024.
Hindmarsh also gave evidence in Lucy Letby’s prosecution. The newly reported findings concern his subsequent involvement in the Birmingham case.



Leave a comment
Join the discussion. Please follow our Community Standards.
Sign in or create an account to leave a comment.
Choose your public display name before submitting. Your email address stays private.
No published comments yet.