Alberta’s government introduced legislation Monday to enact new provincial electoral boundaries, advancing a disputed map that legal experts say could create uncertainty ahead of the Oct. 18, 2027 election if challenged in court.

Justice Minister Mickey Amery expects the bill to pass by year’s end, CBC reporter Joel Dryden reported. The governing United Conservative Party has endorsed the boundaries, while the Opposition NDP has threatened a constitutional challenge.

The proposed map follows an advisory panel report released earlier this month, after a government-led process discarded an initial commission’s plan. Its changes include extending some Calgary ridings beyond municipal boundaries and creating one exclusively urban Lethbridge seat alongside three mixed urban-rural seats.

NDP Leader Naheed Nenshi renewed his accusation Monday that the boundaries amount to gerrymandering and urged UCP members to reject them. He did not outline the party’s next steps, saying a bill could only be challenged after receiving royal assent.

Stephen Thiele, a partner at Toronto law firm Gardiner Roberts, told CBC that a constitutional challenge would likely invoke Section 3 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which protects voting rights. The central issue would be “effective representation,” a principle that balances voter-population equality with considerations such as geography.

Challengers could also seek an injunction preventing the legislation from taking effect, potentially leaving the existing ridings in place for the election, Thiele said.

The possibility of litigation has already prompted concern from Alberta’s election administrator. Chief electoral officer Gordon McClure wrote in late October that the government should retain the current boundaries or postpone the election, citing in part the delays a court challenge could cause.

Constitutional lawyer Marion Sandilands told CBC that Elections Alberta might have to prepare for both the old and new maps. An approaching election would increase the administrative risks a court would need to consider in deciding an injunction request, she said.

Amery rejected McClure’s request, writing that the province saw “no value” in considering hypothetical judicial outcomes and expected Elections Alberta to prepare for the boundaries enacted by the legislature.

Premier Danielle Smith has said the government will assemble a legal team to defend the proposed map as providing effective representation. Retired Alberta Court of Appeal justice Brian O’Ferrall, who led the advisory panel, wrote that he believes its proposals are “not unconstitutional.”

Sources