The Toronto Maple Leafs remain among the NHL’s bottom five despite a strong start from Auston Matthews, with shortcomings in defence, goaltending and secondary scoring undermining their season, according to a November 18 assessment by Sportsnet’s Justin Bourne.
Toronto’s .391 points percentage puts the team in an early hole. Bourne’s review of the club’s pre-season questions finds that Matthews has delivered, but too many of the supporting pieces have not.
Matthews ranks seventh in league scoring while playing alongside Jack Roslovic and Easton Cowan. Bourne also praised his defensive play, distribution and leadership, identifying the top line as one of Toronto’s strengths.
The blue line presents a different picture. Jake McCabe, Chris Tanev, Oliver Ekman-Larsson and Morgan Rielly have combined for no goals across 77 individual games played. Ekman-Larsson, who led Toronto’s defencemen with 39 points last season, has one assist through 23 games.
Bourne assessed McCabe and Tanev as struggling to handle difficult assignments, while noting Tanev’s return from an injury-disrupted year. Rielly has exceeded the columnist’s lowered expectations, but not enough to offset the unit’s limitations.
In goal, Bourne cited Sportlogiq figures placing Sergei Bobrovsky third-worst in goals saved above expected per 60 minutes among goaltenders who have played at least 10 games. Anthony Stolarz has offered a stronger alternative: among goalies with more than 500 minutes, only 12 have a better save percentage.
Secondary offence is another concern. John Tavares went without a point in his five appearances during Toronto’s six-game homestand, and Bourne described the second line as ineffective at both ends. He also questioned coach Jim Hiller’s decisions on goaltending changes and his limited use of rookie Gavin McKenna when chasing games.
There are reasons for some optimism. Toronto is 7-4-2 with Marchenko in the lineup and 1-9-0 without him, though Bourne cautioned against attributing that difference solely to one player. He expects Marchenko’s eventual return and improvement in the team’s combined shooting and save percentages to help.
Still, Bourne’s assessment is that limited cap space and assets leave Toronto with little flexibility to address its broader problems.
Source: Justin Bourne’s Sportsnet analysis of the Maple Leafs’ early-season struggles.




Leave a comment
Join the discussion. Please follow our Community Standards.
Sign in or create an account to leave a comment.
Choose your public display name before submitting. Your email address stays private.
No published comments yet.