Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands have announced plans to transfer people under enforceable removal orders to Rwanda, reviving a contested approach to migration policy that rights groups warn could expose deportees to abuse.
The five European Union governments and Rwanda announced the proposed arrangement in Vienna on Nov. 16, with transfers intended to begin by 2027, Al Jazeera reported. A formal agreement has not been signed, and the governments have not said how many people they expect to send.
The proposed “return hub” would receive people ordered to leave the five countries, including rejected asylum seekers, even if they are not Rwandan. The European governments would pay the direct costs, including temporary accommodation, and fund integration and migrant welfare projects.
According to their joint statement, people transferred would have an opportunity to integrate into Rwandan society. Other options would include voluntarily returning home or travelling to another country they have permission to enter, with assistance from Rwanda and international organisations.
Rwandan Interior Minister Vincent Biruta described the proposal as a “second chance” for people without a right to remain in Europe. Dutch Deputy Prime Minister Bart van den Brink cited Rwanda’s experience hosting migrants and its cooperation with United Nations migration and refugee agencies.
The governments distinguish their proposal from Britain’s abandoned Rwanda scheme, which would have sent asylum seekers arriving irregularly to Rwanda before their claims were assessed. The new plan, they say, would cover only people already legally processed and found not to need protection.
Britain’s Supreme Court ruled its scheme unlawful in 2023, finding a real risk that people transferred could be forcibly returned to countries where they faced abuse. The incoming Labour government scrapped it in 2024.
The UN Refugee Agency, which opposed the British scheme, is advising Rwanda and the five EU governments on the new proposal’s compliance with international human rights law.
Rights organisations remain opposed. A coalition of 47 groups, including the International Rescue Committee, warned that people could be removed from lives established in Europe to places where they have no family or support networks. Human Rights Watch cited risks including arbitrary detention, ill-treatment and destitution, while questioning whether the arrangement would meet EU human rights requirements.



Leave a comment
Join the discussion. Please follow our Community Standards.
Sign in or create an account to leave a comment.
Choose your public display name before submitting. Your email address stays private.
No published comments yet.